Friday, May 3, 2024
24
rated 0 times [  24] [ 0]  / answers: 1 / hits: 10576  / 3 Years ago, sun, may 16, 2021, 3:34:04

There is a command l available on my machine which appears to do nothing. which l also produces no output. Is this a real command, and does it actually do anything?


More From » command-line

 Answers
2

l is an alias for ls -CF, which behaves differently from plain ls.


-C


-C makes ls print output in column form. When stdout is a terminal (rather than being redirected to a file or non-terminal device, or piped to another command), -C is implied. So running ls -C is the same as running ls. But they are not equivalent when ls is redirected or piped. For example:


ek@Kip:~/firefox$ ls
application.ini libfreebl3.chk libxpcom.so
blocklist.xml libfreebl3.so libxul.so
chrome libmozalloc.so mozilla-xremote-client
chrome.manifest libmozsqlite3.so omni.ja
components libnspr4.so platform.ini
crashreporter libnss3.so plugin-container

...

ek@Kip:~/firefox$ ls | less

application.ini
blocklist.xml
chrome
chrome.manifest
components
crashreporter

...

In contrast, ls -C (or -l) outputs in column form regardless of what kind of device stdout is. ls -C | less looks like the top output (but paged by less, of course).


-F


The main visible difference between ls and l is due to the -F flag, which causes ls to append symbolic suffixes (called indicators) to the entries it displays. These indicators identify what kind of file or directory they are.


Compare this to the output of the first ls command above:


ek@Kip:~/firefox$ ls -F
application.ini libfreebl3.chk libxpcom.so*
blocklist.xml libfreebl3.so* libxul.so*
chrome/ libmozalloc.so* mozilla-xremote-client*
chrome.manifest libmozsqlite3.so* omni.ja
components/ libnspr4.so* platform.ini
crashreporter* libnss3.so* plugin-container*

...

Here:



  • / means the entry is a directory.

  • * means the entry is a normal file and is executable (i.e., has executable permissions).

  • The absence of any indicator means the entry is a normal file that is not executable.


There are several other indicators:



The --classify flag and --indicator-style=classify are equivalent to -F.


Source: GNU Coreutils manual, Section 10.1.5 General output formatting


In conclusion, l (ls -CF) is similar to but not the same as ls.


It's also good to keep in mind:


The same text can be both a regular command and an alias.


This is commonly used to specify options that are widely considered both highly useful and harmless, such as automatic colorization (where color is applied when stdout is unredirected or is a terminal, so the escape codes specifying colors are virtually guaranteed not to be misinterpreted).


By this principle, ls is itself an alias.


ek@Kip:/$ alias ls
alias ls='ls --color=auto'

So what command really gets executed when you run l? This one:


/bin/ls --color=auto -CF


  1. The shell (bash) resolves commands that don't contain a / to the first match appearing in PATH, which in Ubuntu for ls is /bin/ls.

  2. Aliases can contain aliases. Alias resolution is not recursive (an alias cannot call itself, though it can call a regular command that has the same name). But it does support nesting.


So l resolves to ls -CF which resolves to ls --color=auto -CF.


Aliases can be changed.


These aliases exist because they're set up that way by default, but every user can change their aliases. See man alias, Chapter 25 and Appendix M in the Advanced Bash-Scripting Guide, and How save my "alias" entries forever.


Related: What do the different colors mean in ls?


[#35391] Tuesday, May 18, 2021, 3 Years  [reply] [flag answer]
Only authorized users can answer the question. Please sign in first, or register a free account.
alkeake

Total Points: 467
Total Questions: 94
Total Answers: 126

Location: Tajikistan
Member since Tue, Jun 15, 2021
3 Years ago
;